May 23, 2005
CCGrid 2005 Recap: The Closest Thing to Being There
By Omer Rana, Cardiff University, et al
The following article was written by: Omer Rana, Linda Wilson, David
Walker, John Oliver, Ali Shaikh Ali, Simone Ludwig, Ian Wootten
of Cardiff University (United Kingdom); Adarsh Patil of University
College (Cork, Ireland); and Brian Foley and Ligang He of Warwick
University (United Kingdom).
---
The 5th IEEE Symposium on Cluster Computing and the Grid (CCGrid 2005)
was held in Cardiff, Wales. The event attracted over 300 delegates from
the United States, Europe and the Asia-Pacific region. It featured four
tutorials, over 75 papers in the main track, nine workshops and a range
of invited talks. The opening speech was given by the Rt Hon Rhodri
Morgan (First Minister for Wales), who welcomed the delegates and
emphasized the importance of knowledge intensive industries and
services as exemplified through e-Science. The conference also featured
17 posters, on topics ranging from Grid middleware to experiments over
Grid infrastructure. Keynote talks were delivered by Carl Kesselman
(USC/ISI) on the recently released Globus Toolkit 4.0 (GT4), and by
Tony Hey (EPSRC) on the UK e-Science Program. Carl Kesselman noted, in
particular, changes in the security infrastructure within GT4. Other
invited talks were by David Pearson (Oracle) on the Enterprise Grid
Alliance, by Stuart Schechter (MIT Lincoln Lab) on SSH/Cluster
security, and Heiko Ludwig (IBM) on WS-Agreement. The use of
WS-Agreement to support contract management was particularly
highlighted by Ludwig, and examples of the use of WS-Agreement were
provided. Additional informational talks were provided by Jorge Gasos
on the European Grid Program, and by Peter McBurney on the European
AgentLink III Network. A "Work-in-Progress" session was initiated at
this event by Mark Baker (Portsmouth University) and Daniel Katz
(JPL/Caltech), and is likely to remain an important part of this
conference in the future. A short course on the use of the Triana
toolkit for distributed workflow was offered to the delegates.
Although an attempt was made to ensure that both Grid and cluster
computing were equally represented at the event, Grid computing
dominated most of the sessions. It was useful to see that a number of
Grid projects which were initiated at the start of this conference
series are now beginning to deliver results. There was also interest in
trying to integrate ideas from cluster and Grid computing, especially
in trying to extend operating system concepts to larger-scale
distributed environments. Based on the presentations, this appears to
be a promising area of work, and many researchers are now beginning to
discuss the general notion of a "Grid Operating System." This theme
also received prominence in the talk of Jorge Gasos from the European
Commission. One aspect presented at the conference was the capability
to federate computational clusters running MOSIX. The work provided
useful insights into techniques for developing a campus wide Grid --
consisting of clusters from different departments running the MOSIX
system.
The applications workshops attracted significant interest and involved
presentations discussing updates to, and application specific
requirements of, Grid infrastructure. The types of applications ranged
from support for electronic learning (e-learning) to bio-informatics
and other applications of health care. There was a significant overlap
in the papers presented at the electronic learning workshop and themes
addressed at the Semantic Grid workshop. The e-learning workshop also
included papers discussing experience of teaching Grid computing
courses to students -- and best practice that could be more widely
applied. Providing business models for Grid services remains an
important concern, and mechanisms for charging for such services were
considered in the Grid Economics workshop. This brought together
participants from the computer science and economics community to
address issues related to electronic contracts and managing strategies
for allocating Grid resources in some fair manner. This issue was also
covered through papers in the main track of the conference. An
excellent tutorial in this area was also delivered by Rajkumar Buyya
from Melbourne University. The tutorial provided an overview of Grid
Computing and mechanisms supported for job management based on an
economic model. There was also discussion of major industry players
working in the area. The tutorial discussed the GridBus, Nimrod-G and
the GridSim Grid Market Directory systems. A very comprehensive
coverage was provided, with particular focus on how economic models
could be used to support scheduling constrained by budget.
The workshop on Cluster Security (chaired by Bill Yurcik) featured
papers addressing disk management, network management and
"rejuvenation" mechanisms. The last of these is a particularly
interesting theme which demonstrates how a cluster can be recovered
after a failure has taken place. The authors also presented a model for
predicting faults within a cluster that could be used as the basis for
a rejuvenation strategy. Presentations and discussions about cluster
infrastructure issues associated with opening up particular ports on a
cluster to allow job submissions and the use of specialist scheduling
systems also formed an important part of the workshop. The enthusiasm
and involvement of the workshop chair led to a very successful event,
and one likely to continue at future CCGrid conferences.
The Peer-2-Peer workshop received the largest number of submissions of
all the workshops. A variety of topics were considered, ranging from
efficient routing mechanisms, resource discovery techniques and the
important area of trust management. Providing incentive structures to
allow users to share content in the P2P environment was also
considered, with particular focus on specialist Grid nodes that host
such services.
Running Data Grid applications such as High Energy Nuclear Physics
(HENP) and weather modelling experiments involves working with huge
data sets possibly of hundreds of terabytes to petabytes in size that
are often kept over wide area networks. This can suffer from overheads
introduced by cross domain connectivity, a variety of different types
of middleware and unreliable infrastructure. This was referred to as
"performability"; that is, the joint consideration of performance and
dependability. This particular theme formed the basis of the 1st
International Workshop on Grid Performability. The properties of
performability that were investigated in the workshops were as follows:
responsiveness, availability, utilization, integrity, throughput,
accessibility, latency, reliability and privacy. The idea was that by
considering the performability of the Grid systems, and hence providing
predictions, administrators can achieve greater impact on system
effectiveness and user satisfaction. An example of the work that was
presented included discussion of an ontology for describing performance
data of Grid workflows. The ontology used to describe a set of
performance metrics are utilized for monitoring and analyzing the
performance of Grid workflows.
The Work in Progress session involved discussion about registries,
networks and messaging as well as workflow. The talks that formed the
basis of this session were expected to have a longer-term focus,
describing primarily issues that are of interest to the research
community, but still at an early stage of exploration. The interaction
between the audience, presenters and the organizers was essential to
provide success for a session of this kind.
The Semantic Grid workshop also attracted a significant audience, and
attempted to bring together individuals with expertise in Semantic Web
technologies and the application sciences. Prominent in this particular
session were the issues of preservation and representation that are
becoming evident with use of Grid computing in scientific applications.
Calls were made on a higher level of semantics for representing both
data and services, to ease the problems of data harmonization such as
scalability and data format differences which will result without them.
In addition to this, general ideas were expressed with such
infrastructures in place, such as the automated composition of
workflows.
Grid applications are often involved with large volumes of data
produced by data-intensive simulations and experiments on scientific
instruments. In order to guarantee seamless automation and
interoperation of distributed data, the need for adequate descriptions
such as semantic-based data descriptions, models, services and systems
becomes crucial. For example, the LHC (Large Hadron Collider) is
expected to be operational by 2006-2007, with the LHC Grid functioning,
to begin the production of simulation data consisting of Petabytes of
data. Sciences such as biomedical science and bioinformatics produce
smaller data sets but numerous, diverse and widely distributed files
stored on individual desktops and databases.
Papers were presented in the areas of resource descriptions,
semi-automatic preservation of scientific data, file-based data for
Grid services and data integration techniques. One particular paper
investigated data integration services in bioinformatics, whereby a
semantic data access and integration service based on the Grid paradigm
was introduced. This service uses ontologies for correlating different
data sets and is a fundamental component of the ProGenGrid system. The
ProGenGrid system is a Grid-enabled platform, which aims at the design
and implementation of a virtual laboratory where e-scientists could
simulate complex "in silico" experiments, composing analysis and
visualization tools available as Web services into a workflow. A number
of other papers were also presented on the general Grid-based workflow
theme, and this remains an important area of concern to both
infrastructure developers and application scientists. Presentations
included discussions of specialist workflow specification languages
(such as AGWL), the development of tools that allow monitoring of tasks
within a workflow session, and tools that allow aggregation of services
from different administrative domains (JISGA and WebCom-G). Many such
workflow techniques are also contained in specialist Problem Solving
Environments aimed at scientists within a particular application area.
Applications considered included Computational Electromagnetics,
real-time systems, and genome comparison. To date, there still does not
appear to be any consensus on a particular workflow technique -- and
often it is difficult to combine workflow tools developed by different
groups.
The use of a shared memory space (such as a tuple space) also remains
an important topic within the Grid and cluster community. The workshop
on Distributed Shared Memory (DSM) featured a number of papers
discussing issues of supporting synchronization within a shared memory,
issues of consistency management, and performance issues associated
with the use of particular networking infrastructure (such as
InfiniBand). The use of DSM to support "Mobile Grids" was a
particularly interesting contribution. The authors discussed how the
use of a Shared Virtual Memory paradigm could be viewed as an
unstructured DSM. The SVM concept was then used to connect PDAs and
similar mobile devices within a Grid.
Network and I/O management also remains an important topic at CCGrid,
with a workshop and three sessions devoted to it. Issues discussed in
the workshop and the main track included deployment of resources within
a "Lambda" network, and in particular how lightpaths allocated to
particular application streams could be more efficiently managed.
Advanced reservation techniques to support a particular Quality of
Service were also discussed. Requirements for a reliable multicast
technique over a production network was discussed, along with an
investigation of how this could be achieved using the NORM protocol
family. The authors also provided a useful discussion of existing
Grid applications (mainly multimedia based) that require the use of
multicast. Papers discussing the provision of efficient I/O over a
cluster provided formed the other theme in the communications track. As
part of the tutorial on high performance I/O, the presenter discussed
file I/O at various levels of abstraction, including POSIX I/O, MPI
file communication primitives, parallel file systems, and libraries
that allow structured access to complex file formats. Some of the
implementation tradeoffs, performance characteristics, and optimization
work on these libraries were described. Since high performance
computing covers a wide range of different kinds of networking and
storage hardware, tools that work well on one system cause severe
bottlenecks in others. Insight was given into when and where it is
appropriate to use one level of abstraction over another, and how to
provide "hints" to the various libraries to allow them to extract the
best out of a given system.
An area that was not represented at CCGrid 2005 included work on sensor
networks, and integration of these with Grid middleware. Although there
is significant interest in this area (at the GGF and various research
groups), especially in health care provision
(http://www.healthgrid.org/), there was not significant representation
of this theme.
This summary of CCGrid cannot fully cover the variety of work presented
at the conference. An attempt is made to present some key themes at the
conference, and to highlight some new and emerging areas of interest to
the community. Interested readers are referred to the proceedings of
CCGrid 2005 for additional information. The next CCGrid conference is
scheduled to take place in Singapore in May 2006. CCGrid 2005
proceedings are available on CD-ROM for purchase, please contact
admin@wesc.ac.uk for more information.